Popular Searches
Useful Links
Innovation and New Product Development Case Study




Case Title:
Nakamura vs Nichia: The Debate over Royalty for Corporate Innovations
Publication Year : 2005
Authors: Roopa & Sumit Kumar Chaudhuri
Industry: Business Law
Region:Japan
Case Code: IPD0021
Teaching Note: Not Available
Structured Assignment: Not Available
Abstract:
Shuji Nakamura (Nakamura), an employee of Nichia Corporation (Nichia) in Japan, invented the world's first blue-LEDs in the mid-1990s. He was paid an annual salary of $100,000. He resigned from Nichia Corporation in 1999 and joined the University of California, Santa Barbara (US) as a professor in the materials department, where he continued to work on LEDs. Prompted by this, Nichia filed a case against Nakamura in 2001 for infringing the patents on the blue LEDs. Nakamura also filed a lawsuit against his former employer demanding a fair share of profits that the company had made by selling his invention. After three years of legal tussle, Nichia paid Nakamura US$8.1 million.
Pedagogical Objectives:
- To discuss the compensation practices of Japanese corporations
- To discuss the effect the Nakamura vs Nichia case had on Japan’s patent laws and recognition practices.
Keywords : Shuji Nakamura,Government and Business Environment Case Study, Nichia Corporation, Employee Invention System in Japan, Japan's corporate culture, Amendments in Japanese Patent Law, US Patent Law, Blue LED's (Light Emitting Diodes), Intellectual property rights, Nakamura's contribution to Nichia, Nichia's profits with blue LEDs, Patent transfer, Japan Inc.
Contents:
- Shuji Nakamura and Nichia Corporation
- Nakamura's 'Victory' over Nichia: Impact on Japan Inc.
Related Case Studies
Recently Bought Case Studies

Managing Innovation - Vol. I
Price: $50
Hardcover edition
ISBN 81-314-0603-2India Inc.: Going Global
Price: $50
Hardcover edition
ISBN 978-81-314-2038-6Change Management
Price: $50
Hardcover edition
ISBN 978-81-314-1483-5- View all Casebooks »
Case Studies On
Course Case Mapping For Financial Management - I
Price: $Course Case Mapping For Financial Management - I
Hardcover editionCourse Case Mapping For Quantitative Methods
Price: $Course Case Mapping For Quantitative Methods
Hardcover editionCourse Case Mapping For Marketing Management - I
Price: $Course Case Mapping For Marketing Management - I
Hardcover edition- View All Course Casemaps»
Course Case Mapping For
An Interview with Personnel of Vaatsalya Group
Price: $Vaatsalya Hospitals (B): The Operational ModelAn interview with Dr. Ashwin Naik & Dr. Veerendra Hiremath
Price: $Vaatsalya Hospitals (A): The Business ModelAn Interview with Dr.Rajiv Malhotra & (Prof)Dr.M.P.Sharma
Price: $Managing a World-Class Hospital: The Rockland Story- View all Video Interviews»
Video Interviews
Training and Development
Executive Brief with Anjali Mukherjee
Highly Recommended for Human Resource Management / Training and Development CourseYou Can't Play by Rules, Always
Executive Brief with R.D. Prasad, Product Manager.
Highly Recommended for Organizational Behavior CourseNew Recruit MBAs Attitudes
Executive Brief with Lopamudra Ray, Keya Gupta and Deepika Lingala.
Highly Recommended for Organizational Behavior Course- View all Executive Briefs»
Executive Brief
Geoffrey Moore
Managing Director at TCG Advisors and a Venture Partner at Mohr Davidow Ventures.
Speaks on InnovationMichael Treacy
Co-founded GEN3 Partners.
Speaks on InnovationSam Kogan
President & Chief Operating Officer of GEN3 Partners.
Speaks on Innovation- View All Executive Interviews»